image_print

Nation – The Australian
Families left in legal limbo as Brisbane Family Court reaches breaking point
Stephen Rice
NSW EDITOR

Listen to this article
6 min
Artwork: Frank Ling
Artwork: Frank Ling

Gift this article
27 Comments
prefer google
Make us preferred on Google
10:18AMNovember 12, 2026.Updated 11:29AMNovember 13, 2026
Hundreds of families seeking resolution for parenting and property disputes have found themselves trapped by potential delays of up to four years because of a crippling lack of judges in the Brisbane family law courts.

While the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia publicly commits to resolving 90 per cent of cases within 12 months of filing, hearing delays have blown timelines open, with some Brisbane families now concerned their cases may not be heard until 2028.

For families who have already been in the queue since 2024, that may mean a delay of four years.

The crisis stems from a compounding shortage of judicial resources in Division 2 – the primary workhorse of the federal family court system – and in particular in the Brisbane registry, where more than 25,000 family law applications were filed in the last financial year alone.

Despite an official allocation of six Division 2 judges for Brisbane, the registry has been forced to function with just three judges following a resignation, an unreplaced retirement, and long-term medical leave.

Federal Attorney-General Michelle Rowland is understood to be working to fill two of the vacancies “imminently” but more than 450 cases are now stuck in this ­administrative limbo.

A spokesperson for the FCFCOA said decisions about judicial appointments are ultimately matters for the government but noted that “the courts have expressed eagerness for the filling of two judicial positions in the Brisbane registry that are currently vacant, and a further position that becomes vacant early in 2027”.

Federal Attorney-General Michelle Rowland during question time at Parliament House, Canberra. Picture: NewsWire / Martin Ollman
Federal Attorney-General Michelle Rowland during question time at Parliament House, Canberra. Picture: NewsWire / Martin Ollman
By May this year, the registry had completely run out of final trial hearing dates for the rest of the calendar year. In response, court administrators created a list of matters without future hearing dates for matters that have passed all procedural checks and are fully ready for trial.

“The list has just grown and grown and grown all year because there’s just nowhere to list them,” one insider told The Australian.

“A matter initiated in 2024 might not get on till 2028. That’s at least another year of uncertainty for that family,” the source said. “There are plenty of cases where kids are at risk, where people are nearly tearing their hair out because they’ve been in the system for two or three years ­already”.

Those involved in Family Law cases cannot be identified but anecdotal evidence suggests delays are causing immense emotional strain, inflating legal bills by tens of thousands of dollars, and leaving children suspended in prolonged uncertainty.

In a bid to manage the growing problems, Chief Justice Will Alstergren has scheduled an emergency five-day “callover” event at the end of this month listing approximately 400 to 450 matters.

Under the plan, the Chief Justice and two other judges will hear up to 30 matters a day each during the week to speed up settlements or push parties into mediation.

The court has billed it as “an opportunity for family law practitioners to encourage settlement and resolution by listing matters to a range of court-based and private dispute resolution events”.

“The Court seeks the goodwill of practitioners in the lead-up to this callover so that it can help as many families as possible in reaching an amicable, safe and equitable resolution to their family law proceedings.”

Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia chief justice William Alstergren
Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia chief justice William Alstergren
However, insiders and legal practitioners have criticised the move as an inefficient administrative exercise that has resulted in additional burden on parties and practitioners, further delay to the listing of matters, and administrative chaos.

“The idea is to encourage parties to settle and go to mediation but the majority of matters needing a trial date have already been through the courts process including mediations and exhausted those avenues. It’s difficult to see the Chief Justice’s callover as much more than a performative exercise. The solution is to appoint more judges.”

“We’re operating with 12 judges [including six Division 1 judges], but Melbourne has 24,” the source said. “Then a couple of weeks ago, two more judges were appointed for the Melbourne registry, which raises the question of the reason for the delay in the Brisbane appointments, which seems disproportionate.”

Adding to the bottleneck is the wide territory served by the Brisbane registry. Unlike jurisdictions like NSW which has separate registries in the Sydney CBD, Parramatta, Wollongong and New­castle, the Brisbane registry services the entire metropolitan area, Moreton Bay, and the Sunshine Coast. The jurisdiction extends to northern NSW and coastal Queensland circuits such as Rockhampton and Bundaberg.

In a statement, the court spokesperson said there were “currently” no matters listed in the Brisbane Registry that had been allocated a final hearing date in 2028.

However, the court source told The Australian: “The problem is 2027 hasn’t been listed yet because of the delays, so no one’s got trial dates yet.”

The court spokesperson said that nationally, the Courts’ Annual Report records a median time from filing to finalisation of 10 months for family law final order applications in the last financial year. However, the statement did not address The Australian’s question about how the Brisbane registry had fared against a target of resolving 90 per cent of matters within 12 months of filing.

A spokesperson for Ms Rowland said: “The government has been working with the court to identify and prioritise areas of need and will continue to make merit-based appointments where vacancies arise.”

Editor’s note: This article has been amended to clarify the total number of Divsion 1 and 2 judges.

If you know more: stephenrice1@protonmail.com

More Coverage
Secret texts reveal prosecutors drafted Dowling support letter knowing it would leak
Secret texts reveal prosecutors drafted Dowling support letter knowing it would leak
STEPHEN RICE
A-G fires up fresh legal war with watchdog referral
A-G fires up fresh legal war with watchdog referral
Stephen Rice
Top law firm sacks ‘cunning and deceitful’ lawyer
Top law firm sacks ‘cunning and deceitful’ lawyer
STEPHEN RICE